When Terry Crews stepped onto the stage of the Dolby Theatre for America's Got Talent Season 20Hollywood, California in May, fans expected dazzling acts — but not a behind-the-scenes wish list for a new judge. Yet, in an exclusive September 3, 2025 interview with NBC Insider, Crews dropped a bombshell: Spike Lee is his dream addition to the panel. "He doesn't hold back," Crews said. "That's another thing. You know with his personality, I really think it would be electric and exciting. That would be an awesome."
It’s not just flattery. Crews, who’s hosted 194 episodes of AGT since Season 15, spoke with the reverence of someone who’s been personally transformed by Lee’s work. "Do the Right Thing changed my life," he told reporter Elizabeth Logan. "When I watched it, I was a young man and all of a sudden my mind was blown because this movie was incredible." The 56-year-old actor and former NFL defensive end didn’t just cite Lee’s filmography — he saw in him a rare ability to spot raw, untamed talent. "Somebody... very emotional, and had a tremendous voice... Spike would probably put him in a movie, they'd be doing the soundtrack of his next film," Crews added. "He's that kind of guy."
Why Spike Lee Makes Sense — and Why He Won't Join
Lee, 67, is no stranger to high-stakes creative environments. A National Medal of Arts recipient, he’s directed landmark films like Malcolm X (1992) and BlacKkKlansman (2018), which earned him an Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay. His voice is unapologetic, his critiques sharp, and his storytelling deeply human — qualities that could elevate AGT beyond flashy performances into conversations about culture, identity, and artistic integrity.
But here’s the twist: Lee has never expressed interest in joining a reality show. And while Crews is clearly enthusiastic, he’s not pushing for it. "I’m not the guy who decides," he clarified. "I’m just the guy who says, ‘Hey, wouldn’t this be cool?’" The reality is, AGT’s producers aren’t likely to shake up a panel that’s been stable since early 2025 — especially after Mel B’s return was officially announced on March 15, 2025.
The Current Panel: A Mix of Power and Personality
The current judging lineup is a carefully balanced cocktail of global influence and distinct styles. Simon Cowell, 75, remains the show’s architect — the man who built the format, now in his 19th year on the panel. His blunt critiques are legendary, his business acumen undeniable. Sofia Vergara, 52, brings warmth and Hollywood glamour, often defending contestants with emotional insight. Howie Mandel, 69, is the comic relief and emotional anchor — though he missed the September 10, 2025 episode, with no official reason given. And Mel B, 49, returned after a six-year hiatus, bringing back the fiery energy that made her a fan favorite from 2013 to 2018.
Here’s the odd thing: None of the current judges were on the show when it launched in 2006. The panel has been completely overhauled twice. That history of change makes Crews’ suggestion less outlandish than it seems. If AGT can swap out judges every few seasons, why not add a visionary filmmaker?
Crews: Host, Not Judge — and the Bodyguard of Talent
Despite his admiration for Lee, Crews is adamant about one thing: he won’t take a judge’s seat. "That’s not my thing," he told People magazine. "I am 100% the bodyguard of talent." His role, he says, is to console, to guide, to be the calm after the storm. "I give them all the good advice when they come off. If it didn’t go well, I console them. So I love that."
It’s a role he’s perfected. His custom suits — like the bronze number with oversized bow shoes he wore on September 17, 2025 — aren’t just fashion. They’re armor. A visual signal that he’s not here to critique the act. He’s here to protect the dream.
What’s Next for AGT?
With Season 20 airing through September and the finale scheduled for mid-November, the judging panel is expected to remain unchanged. But Crews’ comments have already sparked online chatter. Could Lee be a guest judge? A one-time mentor? The show has brought on special guests before — from Jennifer Hudson to David Beckham. A cameo from Lee wouldn’t be out of the question.
Meanwhile, Crews has also floated the idea of Chris Rock, 59, joining the panel — though he admits having two comedians (Rock and Mandel) might be too much. If Mandel ever leaves, Rock would be the logical heir.
And what about the prize? Still $1 million. Still filmed at the Dolby Theatre. Still streamed on Peacock. The formula hasn’t changed — but maybe, just maybe, the next season will.
Why This Matters Beyond the Stage
This isn’t just about a TV show. It’s about who gets to decide what art matters. AGT has always been a platform for the overlooked — the 7-year-old opera singer, the 68-year-old tap dancer, the immigrant family with a folk band. Lee’s lens, shaped by decades of telling stories about Black America, could bring depth to a show often criticized for being superficial. He doesn’t just see talent. He sees testimony.
And that’s the quiet revolution Crews is hinting at: what if judging isn’t just about whether someone can sing or juggle — but whether they’ve got something to say?
Frequently Asked Questions
Why would Spike Lee be a good fit for AGT’s judging panel?
Spike Lee brings a rare combination of artistic vision, cultural insight, and unfiltered honesty. Having directed films like Do the Right Thing and BlacKkKlansman, he’s proven he can recognize raw, emotional talent and elevate it into powerful storytelling. His direct communication style could push contestants to dig deeper, turning performances into narratives — not just tricks.
Has Spike Lee ever been involved in reality TV before?
No, Spike Lee has never served as a judge or regular panelist on a reality competition. He’s made cameos in scripted shows like Atlanta and Black-ish, but his focus has remained on film and social commentary. His potential involvement with AGT would be a major departure — and a sign the show is willing to evolve beyond traditional talent formats.
Who are the current judges on AGT Season 20?
The current judging panel consists of Simon Cowell (75), Sofia Vergara (52), Howie Mandel (69), and Mel B (49). Mel B returned in March 2025 after a six-year break, replacing Heidi Klum. All four judges were appointed in early 2025, and the panel has remained stable despite Mandel’s unexplained absence during the September 10 episode.
Could Terry Crews ever become a judge?
Crews has explicitly said no. He calls himself the "bodyguard of talent," emphasizing his role as a supportive host who consoles contestants after their performances. He doesn’t want to critique — he wants to uplift. His job is to create space for others to shine, not to be the one passing judgment.
What’s the prize for winning AGT Season 20?
The winner of AGT Season 20 receives a $1 million cash prize and a headlining residency in Las Vegas. The auditions were held at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, California, and the finale is scheduled for mid-November 2025. The prize structure has remained unchanged since Season 1 in 2006, though the format of the residency has evolved over the years.
Why did Mel B return to AGT after leaving in 2018?
Mel B returned in March 2025 after NBC reportedly reached out to her following a successful reunion special. Her fiery personality and strong connection with contestants were seen as key to revitalizing the show’s energy. Her return also helped stabilize the panel after Heidi Klum’s departure, offering continuity for longtime fans while bringing back the emotional authenticity that defined her original tenure.
